Showing posts with label Abelard and Heloise. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Abelard and Heloise. Show all posts

May 17, 2024

My liner notes for the recording at Essen Festival.


"Despite not being at least initially among the scheduled groups (in fact, the band’s name does not appear on the poster or the official program for the event), Third Ear Band played at the Zweites Essener Pop & Blues Festival on April 24, 1970. 

The evening’s packed program included, among others, The Flock, Ekseption, Rhinocerous, The Groundhogs, It’s A Beautiful Day, and the still-unknown Black Sabbath, who had recently debuted their self-titled album. 

Coming to Essen (Germany), Third Ear Band stayed overnight at the Rheinischer Hof hotel at Edwig Strass 11 (four band members, manager Steve Pank, and two sound engineers), and on the evening of the 24th, between 9 and 10 p.m., they played their set on the main stage. 
On that first evening, in the long afternoon that began at 4 p.m. with bands taking turns on two stages, the Groundhogs had played just before them, and the Oscar Benton Band would play after them. The first of the festival’s two days ended at 2 a.m. with a performance by The Flock. 

Other times, one would say, considering the sad homogenisation of today. Times when progressive, blues rock, hard rock and folk music could be played in the same festival. 

It was thanks to an enlightened young man, Konrad Mallison, who in 1969 had emptied the intuition to invent the most famous alternative music festival ever held in Germany, only after attending the Bath Festival of Blues the year before, while on holiday in England. 


The 49 minutes of Third Ear Band’s live set, recorded by NDR TV, ending with what appears to be the tuning of the instruments, suggests that the length of the gig was longer and that at least one or two tunes are missing from the roll call. But the extraordinariness of this find, the quality of the sound, and the choice of music performed, make this set worthy of going down in history among the few other great bargains available in the catalogue (e.g., along with the wonderful concert filmed by French TV on May 28, 1970 and available on the Web) in one of the most interesting phases of the band’s history. 
In fact, the concert in Essen, played by the quartet line-up with Sweeney on hand drums, Minns on oboe, Coff on violin and Smith on cello, falls just a few weeks before the release of the second album, known among fans as “Elements” despite being titled simply “Third Ear Band” (released in June 1970), and the recording, also in Germany (on July 2 and 3), of the stunning soundtrack for NDR TV animation short movie “Aebelard” by film maker George Morse with overexposed psychedelic illustrations by painter Herbert Fuchs. 

Entitled “Abelard & Heloise,” it is one of Third Ear Band’s most significant works, which remained unpublished for almost thirty years (it only come out in 1997 with my first book on the band) and which would have deserved to be released even then. 

Of these two excellent works, in Essen the band premiered shortened versions of “Earth” and “Water” and one of the six-part soundtrack, the third, featuring a beautiful oboe theme by Paul Minns. It’s interesting to catch the group just during the Abbey Road recordings (held in a few sessions in April and May 1970) at a stage when these tracks still seem to be in progress: “Water,” whose earliest recordings dated months before, was here reprised in a version with a minor key and it is very short compared to the one later released, limited to a repetition of the main theme without the improvised studio variations. 

Even more surprising is the performance of “Earth,” only 3:00, much shorter than the album recording, with Ursula Smith engaged in pizzicato and Coff playing his violin with a plectrum. In between the two novelties and the excerpt from “Aebelard,” in Essen the band offered old “Alchemy”’s warhorses they had been playing for over a year in concert such as “Druid One,” with an unexpected vocal intro, “Ghetto Raga,” “Mosaic,” and “Area Three” (but without John Peel’s Jews Harp!), showing a incredibly brilliant interplay: the structure of the compositions, whether raga scales or free improvisation, is based on Sweeney’s hypnotic rhythms (however, not always precise) and Smith’s cello, with predominantly a rhythmic function, on which Minns’ oboe and Coff’’s violin phrasing are grafted – now rigorous, in chasing each other on the raga scales, now erratic, unpredictable. 

The final effect, caught in its slow, mesmerising unraveling, also renders the atmosphere of the festivals of these years, with a participating and attentive audience, eager to hear the music even when, between tunes, the musicians indulge in tuning their instruments or simply catching their breath. 

From this concert, filmed by German TV, only the performance of “Earth” has been circulating on the web for a few years now, and is part of a DVD documenting the festival (titled “Pop & Blues Festival 1969-1970,” it was not officially released in USA by RareRock DVDs)."  


Tracklist

Side A: 1. Water 03:50 2. Abelard & Heloise (Part 3) 06:08 3. Mosaic 05:41 4. Area Three 07:58 

Side B: 1. Druid One 05:47 2. Ghetto Raga 07:50 3. Earth 03:11 total: 40:25 min.
 
 
no©2024 LucaChinoFerrari (unless you intend to make a profit. In which case, ask first)

June 20, 2022

A 40 minutes unrealised recording from a 1970 TEB live gig in Germany found!

In the last few weeks, Michael Schutz of Mig Music wrote me for asking some help about how to contact original members of the TEB because he has found a 40' UNREALISED LIVE RECORDING from a 1970 gig. He wrote me this:

"Mig Music has been working with the German state TV station WDR since 2009 and WDR is the producer of the TV series " Rockpalast " which is recognised worldwide as a music/rock/TV format. 

WDR has always used its own sound engineers for the recordings of Rockpalast but also for other musically valuable festivals. One of these gentlemen was Joachim Manfred Kaiser, who two or three years ago told the current chief editor of the Rockpalast programme that he still had extensive security copies of recordings of the Rockpalast from 1975 onwards, the Berlin Jazztage since around 1968 and also of the Essen Pop and Blues Festival, and that he would like to hand them back to his former employer.

There were recordings of about 100 minutes from 1969 with the Keef Hartley Band and from 1970 with the Keef Hartley Big Band. The last living musician who founded the band together with Keef is Miller Anderson. We are friends. Miller got 12 minutes of the recordings and immediately agreed to release them. The quality of the recordings is incredibly good, considering that the tapes are 52 years old.

The tapes also include a performance by the Third Ear Band from the 1970 festival in the Grugahalle in Essen, which is just over 40 minutes long. We know from the Keef Hartley tapes how uniquely high and therefore good the quality of the recordings by the sound engineer Kaiser are. These are always radio recordings. Not like the Rockpalast for TV, he was the sound engineer for the music radio departments of the WDR.

Unfortunately, there is no further information about the recordings, such as which pieces are involved and which artists were on stage in Essen.

I would therefore ask you to inform us who we should contact from the band. With Glen Sweeney or with Dave Tomlin or maybe with Paul Minns? This has nothing to do with EMI and nothing to do with Cherry Red. Here only the musicians who were on stage have the right to say yes or no."

I explained him, as we know, that the band played at least four times in Germany with two different line-ups, one acoustic (for example, for the "Abelard & Heloise" TV soundtrack) and one electric (for the appearance on "Beat Club" TV programme).

So he assuered me he will send some excerpts just to detect the band  musicians and the titles of tracks... 

Could be this another buried treasure?

no©2022 LucaChinoFerrari (unless you intend to make a profit. In which case, ask first.

November 23, 2018

The remastered "Elements" album out now!


Thanks, Cherry Red Records-Esoteric Recordings here's the wonderful remastered album every TEB fans was waiting...


The "Elements" album is now out in a brilliant 3CDs edition with:

- the original legendary four tracks about elements (1970 Harvest album) 
- the complete "Abelard & Heloise" TV soundtrack (remastered from the original German masters);
- twenty unrealized tracks from the vaults and BBC radio sessions (1970-1971): actually the real unrealized tracks are eight, because the other tracks included are "Abelard & Heloise" soundtrack (6 tracks) and two radio programmes already realised by Gonzo Multimedia  (6 tracks);
- a long historical essay by your devote LCF...

                                                (photos by  Elena Blasi)





 






  









no©2018 Luca Chino Ferrari (unless you intend to make a profit. In which case, ask first)

August 19, 2018

Brand new Third Ear Band album out soon!



Soon Cherry Red Records (https://www.cherryred.co.uk/) edits a brand new triple CDs of TEB's music related to the wonderful 1970 second album (a.k.a. "The Elements"). 
The package shows newly remastered edition of the studio album and the full "Abelard & Heloise" TV soundtrack, two rare BBC radio sessions and 8 (eight!!!) totally never issued studio tracks from the Abbey Road vaults (among them the legendary "Mistress of the Sun" recorded in 1971 and different studio takes of "Earth" and "Air"). 
The booklet is edited by Luca Chino Ferrari.

 no©2018 Luca Chino Ferrari (unless you intend to make a profit. In which case, ask first)

May 13, 2017

TEB special on Italian rock magazine: old bad habits on a new magazine...


Monthly magazine "Classic Rock" (issue 54) published this month two new articles about the TEB, one on their story with references to the Sixties/Seventies popular music aesthetics and the first albums; one on the relation between their music and scores ("Abelard & Heloise" and "Macbeth" soundtracks).


Full of many little factual historiographic errors, the first piece (simply titled "Third Ear Band") written by Marco Braggion is a patchy and omitting excursus through the TEB first phase story, with references to musicians and records of that time, but with very bold time gaps   (i.e.: the journalist states that  "If man but knew" by Habibiyya, published in 1972, was a clear reference for many groups of the time, one of the first example of "world music"...!) and arguable point of views. 
Ignoring the extraordinary tracks of the National Balkan Ensemble (now available on Gonzo's "Necromancers of the Drifting West"), recorded in late 1968/beginning '69, just at the end of the piece he dismisses the last artistic period of the band (1988-1992) with this shallow and debatable way: "After these outputs ["Abelard & Heloise" and "Macbeth" soundtracks], the band splits [sic!], but it will come back in '90's [sic!] with some albums that travel on more predictable tracks - pieces alterning verse and chorus and an use of the voice codified on a suspended Rock music between that psychedelic mood of the beginning and some electronic New Age scent.", showing that he evidently never listened to the live works "Live Ghosts" (1989) and "New Forecasts from the Third Ear Almanac" (1989), and more recent Gonzo's live CDs. 
Again, no discography, no references to this Archive, nor a mention to my book published in 1999, before that (at least) in Italy all the journalists was repeating the same old abused commonplaces about the band. (Now it's easy, you know, one journalist goes in Internet and can cut & paste everything from this Archive using that as he was the real author of it...).
Great Italian music journalism!

Better the second piece written by  (old) good journalist Giandomenico Curi titled "Visions and soundtracks", where he analyze the soundtracks TEB recorded for "Abelard" (German TV 1971) and "Macbeth" by Polanski with some interesting  sparks about the relation between visions and music in the TEB experience.

Anyway, here below you can read (just in Italian, sorry!) the complete special (given to me by friend Mirco Delfino of the TEB Facebook page at https://www.facebook.com/third.ear.band/) and form your own opinion...


no©2017 Luca Chino Ferrari (unless you intend to make a profit. In which case, ask first)   

September 03, 2016

"Movements" on the Net around the Third Ear Band...


It's clear to me the Third Ear Band is an evergreen band! The evidence of it is that the Net is still interested into TEB's music and often bloggers/fans/ journalists dedicate pages to Our Alchemical Esoteric Band.
From the beginning of this year I like to advise some interesting stuff:

in Februry 2016 French Web site "Rythmes Croisés" wrote a review on "Exorcisms" at http://www.rythmes-croises.org/quand-third-ear-band-pratiquait-lexorcisme/; then, Web site "Pound for Pound" published two inspired pieces in March 2016 on "Alchemy" and "Third Ear Band" at http://www.poundforpound.us/music/2016/6/1/third-ear-band-alchemy and at http://www.poundforpound.us/music/2016/6/5/third-ear-band-third-ear-band
showing is still possible to write personal ideas about the music,   despite the discouraging social networks' attitude just to post music, pictures and video without a word, ideas, opinions, analysis... (but, yes, "I like it"...).






Again in last March, on the strange "Mouser" site such "Isidis" wrote a very inspired thing about "Abelard & Heloise" soundtrack, a short personal speculation about love... (http://www.wearemouser.org/third-ear-band-abelard-and-heloise/ ).
And what about the sale of  a "Third Ear Band - Collection of 4 x original issue LPs on EMI Harvest from this experimental rock" on the site "The Saleroom" of Warrington (Cheshire, UK) for an estimate price of 60-80 GPB (read here)?


no©2016 Luca Ferrari (unless you intend to make a profit. In which case, ask first)       

March 25, 2016

"Born in Canterbury": a case of Italian crap journalism about the TEB.


Some Italian pseudo-music journalists have the sad habit to repeat the same old tragically fake infos about the Third Ear Band. One of the worst one is named Cesare Rizzi, an author involved with the important publisher Giunti on "guides to" some kind of music.

He wrote three books about the so-called Progressive scene (1999, 2003 and 2010) annoting coincise profiles about bands as King Crimson, Pink Floyd... and fatally (but I'm not agreed with this) the Third Ear Band.
On the volumes he states the band was born in Canterbury!, when even kids know Glen Sweeney's ensemble was born in London Ladbroke Grove.

But one of the thing that really upset me is when Rizzi tells about the last phase of the band story (the reunion and the records made in Italy): he alludes to a "bunch of Italian fans", not quoting me (a writer about music since 1985) and my friend Gigi Bresciani (one of the most important promoter in Italy)as the only responsible of the band reunion and the very first concerts played here; nor the only book existing on the band (with the very first edition of the "Abelard & Heloise" soundtrack) - "Necromancers of the Drifting West", published by Stampa Alternativa in Rome - written by me (where he could take some verified infos about the Thirds).

An hateful way to make journalism, superficial and amateurish; writing just in Italian they can omitting the truth, but the clever and really passionate fans around the world know where they can find the right stuff!

no©2016 Luca Ferrari (unless you intend to make a profit. In which case, ask first)

November 24, 2014

"Abelard & Heloise" short film revealed!


Finally I've received from BRMitschnitt a copy of the original short film directed by George Moorse in 1970 for German TV with the soundtrack by the Third Ear Band and the screen adaptation by Austrian painter Ernst Fuchs.

 


Originally titled just "Abaelard", is about 1-hour movie with actors and few animations. Quite static, sometimes it shows some sort of psychedelic effects; all in all it's a boring narration of the well-known love story, most of all more silent sequences than acted ones, with a great prominence to the wonderful Third Ear Band music.


An important, even if artistically arguable finding, this movie was one of the obscure gems in the TEB's story. 
However I frankly doubt some producers could be interested into making an official DVD from this, considering the scarce artistic value (apart the TEB music, of course!) and the boring screen adaptation.


For those who has lost to listen to the wonderful TEB's soundtrack, just recently we have "Abelard & Heloise" available on Spotify at   http://open.spotify.com/album/40HstH0XLT4CzP5laguZHy



no©2014 Luca Ferrari (unless you intend to make a profit. In which case, ask first)  

October 04, 2014

"Abelard and Heloise" short TV film update.


Ernst Fuchs & Yoko Ono
Hi TEB folks,
Ghetto Raga has got a kind reply about the way to get a copy of the legendary 1970 short film "Abelard & Heloise" directed by George Moorse with the soundtrack recorded by Glen Sweeney and C. live in the studio (read here).

Even if the film is not available in any official video format, as for the 1971 German TV clip (read here) you can ask NDR to buy a DVD-R of it for €40 (taxes and P.P. included) payble through the bank. 


E. Fuchs, "The Glorious Rosary" (1954-1961)

For arrangements write to:






NDR Mitschnittservice
Hugh-Greene-Weg 1
[D] 22529 Hamburg

tel: 49 [040]-44192-446
fax: 49[040]-44192-443
mitschnittservice@ndr.de
www.ndrmedia/mitschnittservice.de
 no©2014 Luca Ferrari (unless you intend to make a profit. In which case, ask first)  

September 22, 2014

"Abelard & Heloise" German short film found!



After long researches, Ghetto Raga Archive is proud to confirm that a copy of the legendary short movie "Abelard & Heloise" with the Third Ear Band original soundtrack is taken by the archive of  Bayerischer Rundfunk (Germany).
This is a data sheet of the film: 

Title: "Peter Abelard - Third Ear Band"
Transmission: 06.12.1970
Duration: 58'35"
Programme: Film and Teleclub
Produced by: Barbara Moorse Film-Workshop
Authors: George Moorse (LitVorl)
                 Tanja Oulebla (LitVorl)
Screenplay: Ernst Fuchs
                      Hans Gailling
Director: George Moorse
Actors: Philippa Stjernsward
Music by: The Third Ear Band
Camera: Gerard Vandenberg
Fernsehspiel von George Moorse and Tanja Oulebla
From the classic love story between Abelard and Heloise adapted for the screen by wiener malers Ernst Fuchs.

 

Ghetto Raga Archive is still waiting for a reply to understand if and how it is possible to get a copy of the film...

no©2014 Luca Ferrari (unless you intend to make a profit. In which case, ask first)  

February 06, 2012

A PhD thesis about medievalism with some parts on TEB's "Abelard and Heloise"


Englishman Eamon Kevin Byers is working on a PhD thesis about the relationship between folk music and medievalism. In the past months, he has contacted me in order to get some infos about the TEB involvement with the "Abelard and Heloise" and "Macbeth" scores.

Abelard and Heloise in a manuscript of the "Roman de la Rose" (14th century)

Here are the e-mails:

"Dear Luca,
Firstly can I express my admiration for the fantastic work you are doing on 'Ghetto Raga'? I am currently researching the Third Ear Band's music for 'Macbeth' and 'Abelard& Eloise' as part of the much wider topic of my PhD thesis and have found your site incredibly useful and informative. I am writing to ask if you could help me with a couple of things. Firstly, your chronology appears to miss out some text on the right hand side of the screen. Is this a problem on my end? If not, could I possibly ask you to email me the text pertaining to the recording of 'Macbeth'? Secondly, do you have any further information on the film 'Abelard and Heloise'? It has been suggested to me that the director, Fuchs, is Herbert Fuchs, an Austrian director who died in 2006. Is this correct?
Thank you very much, keep up the good work with the archive.
Yours sincerely,
Eamon Byers"
(October 12th, 2010)



 "Hi.
These are all the stuffs in the Archive about Macbeth and A&H.
Good work.
Luca "
(October 12th, 2010)

"Hi Luca,
a million thanks for your help, the information on the two films is fantastic. I'm determined to find out more about 'Abelard& Heloise' and will pass on anything I find out. As for my thesis, it's on the relationship between folk music and medievalism, so my work on the Third Ear Band is only a very small part of it, but if I come up with anything that might be useful for the site I'll pass that on too.
Thanks again,
Eamon".

Abelard & Heloise

"Hi Eamon.
What's about that very interesting research? Do you like to write something about it for the archive?
Luca" 
(December 31th, 2011)

"Hi Luca,
Sorry for the terrible delay in replying. Your email seemed to get lost over Christmas! Thank you very much for your email, I would certainly be interested in writing something for the archive if I come up with something worthwhile. I shall keep in touch.
Best wishes,
Eamon"
(January 31th, 2012)

So if someone knows something more about "Abelard and Heloise" (does it exist the original score somewhere?) or filmmaker Herbert Fuchs, please  contact me through my personal e-mail.

no©2012 Luca Ferrari (unless you intend to make a profit. In which case, ask first)

December 11, 2009

The National Balkan Ensemble a.k.a. The Third Ear Band: another mystery cleared up.


1. Web miracles 
Around the Spring of 2005, on a pair of Web sites (www.wfmu.org/playlists/show/8498 and http://myweb.tiscali.co.uk/ultimatheule/encyclopedia/a-z.htm), emerged an obscure Sixties album of such The National Balkan Ensemble, "the Third Ear Band in incognito!" as someone wrote. Firstly, having worked for many years to the reconstruction of band's history and having ignored the existence of it, my first reaction was incredulity and skepticism: I thought it was a classical Web fake, and decided to let it go...
Even because during the long period I frequented Sweeney and the other guys none told me about this "parallel project", nor about that it could be a typical Rock 'trick' (a good example of it it's the Duke of Stratosphere, the psychedelic XTC...). So I decided to wait, thinking to ask Carolyn some details about the thing. 

2. A strange event 
Some time later (July 17th, 2005), really unexpectedly, it happens a strange event. Ben Cartland, through my old (and now dead) Web site (http://lucaferrari.net), contacted me about the project to dedicate an album to Paul Minns, that had committed suicide. He wrote: "It was fascinating finding/reading your article on the Net. Some info, expecially concerning the early years (well, years when I was considerably involved in the band) seems to strike my memory, which has also dimmed over the years concerning all details, as not quite accurate. Not that it matters anyway. It was tragic to hear about Paul's death - he and I made a lot of music together (before Richard Coff appeared on the scene). and I'll always remember him (his musical sensitivity) with respect and affection. It's very good the compilation's dedicated to his memory. Well, just thought I'd send this... don't expect a reply but feel free to do so if you wish. Best regards, Ben Cartland (ex Viola player, Third Ear Band)". At the time of my book on the band, none told me where Cartland were: I could ask him some questions about the origins of the group. For myself, as for Richard Coff, even Ben Cartland had been swallowed up by the Black Hole of time... 

3. Discovering the original NBE's album (thanks to Sean Sedayne) 
At that point, one of the few (but good) TEB's fans that sometime contacted me to talk about the group - Sean Sedayne - wrote me to present a copy of the National Balkan Ensemble record, convinced that group was the Third Ear Band at the very beginning of its career: "The record is dated 1970, but this features the viola of Benjamin Cartland who I understand was a member of the group prior to the recording of "Alchemy" - no dates, or locations are given but the music is charmingly 'primitive' compared to the focussed intensity of "Alchemy" and "AEFW" - in the first piece Sweeney plays finger cymbals throughout!". I've gotten the CD where Sean reversed the old vynil and - incredible! - three tracks sounded really as the "Alchemy"-era Third Ear Band! At the oboe attack, just after few seconds, I was totally sure: no doubts the player was the great Paul Minns! 

4. The original album track-list 
So, I verified the few data on the record cover: 

1. Cosmic Trip (5.45) 
Freely expressive, mainly dissonant, constant instrumental interplay, occasional rhythm changes, feat. violin, cello, oboe, percussion. 
2. Jason's Trip (6.17) 
As above. 
3. Devil Weed (3.41) 
As above. 
Composers: Sweeney/Coff/Minns/Cartland 

The tracks sequence (around 16 minutes) occupies just a side of the album, on the other side there are seven tracks played by another group - Comedy Links and Bridges.

The album was published by Standard Music Library (catalogue n° ESL112), a London record company born in 1965 that produced many pop bands (it's still in full activity with a tiny catalogue of 'muzak' CD).


The cover, probably a record company impersonal (and quite insignificant) cliché, shows the drawing of a bunch of instruments put there to suggest the image of a grotesque face. There's no indications about data and location wherethe music was recorded.
Sound, instruments and band line-up confirmed it was a collection of recordings made before "Alchemy", probably played in the second half of 1968 when, after idiosyncratic electric guitarist Clive Kingsley's split, followed by the well-known electric instruments and Sweeney's drum-kit theft, the band became an acoustic quartet.
The album, edited just on vynil, is now very very rare, valued on collector's market about 150-200 euros...


5. Some historical references
According the Paul Minns' diary the first documented gig played by the new line-up was on July 3th, when the musicians was at The Crypt (London) with Pete Brown  & The Battered Ornaments and Ron Geesin.
Just before "Alchemy" recording sessions (February or March 1969?), the quartet played surely also on October 20th at Country Club (London) for a "Time Out" benefit gig, and on November 28th at the All Saints Hall in Powis Garden (London), legendary place where Pink Floyd with Syd Barrett begun.
It was just in those days Peter Jenner met Sweeney proposing to him to become group's manager with his friend Andrew King (as Blackhill Enterprises): always at Powis Gardens DJ Pete Drummond presented John Peel to the band...
TEB most important gig with that line-up was anyway at "The Alchemical Wedding" at the Royal Albert Hall of London on December 18th. An happening managed by Jim Haynes with, among others, Yoko Ono and John Lennon: haddled in a sack in the middle of the stage, they had TEB's music as a soundtrack...



A short article published on "International Time" n. 43 (November 1th-14th 1968), with a rare photo of the band (see above), confirm the acoustic turning: "... the amps were stolen and the Third Ear Band founded itself finished. They thought about it and decided that they would carry on acousticly. The group now consisted of Paul oboe, Ben Cartland viola, Glen drums, and a new member Richard violin, they came to the Arts Lab and the music began to happen again. None of the musicians know what or how it happens, they just play. What is the music like? Well, one chick admitted confidentially to Jim Haynes that she experienced two complete orgasms while listening to the Third Ear band".

Just at the beginning of "Alchemy" recording sessions in Abbey Road studios, that lasted one week-end only (a six hours session with track recorded in one take!), Cartland suddenly left the band.
"Cartland announced after two tracks that he wanted to play keyboard instead the viola!", remembered Minns (1996). "As this was totally unexpected and unexceptable he quit. He tended to be volatile and was very hippy".
From that session with Cartland one track titled "Raga in D" has left, the copy on a reel Minns kept at his home for years with the marvellous 1970 soundtrack "Abelard and Heloise": it's quite impossible, knowing praxis used in that years in recording experience, that have survived other tracks in Abbey Road vaults...
"I nearly cried when I heard this. It was like the return of an old friend. This raga is called in D and was the nucleus for ragas such as "Area Three" and "Ghetto Raga", both in the "Alchemy" album. This track should have been on as well as it was recorded at the start of that session..." (Minns, 1996).

The same band, with Cartland (not Courtland as often reported) on viola, played just "Ghetto Raga", "Druid" and "Hyde Park raga" in the first "John Peel Session" on February 11th 1969 (producer: John Walters), session aired on next July 27th (see on the officla John Peel Web site at http:www.keepingitpeel).

Comparing the three tracks recorded as National Balkan Ensemble with this "Raga in D" Abbey Road Recording, it turns out to be inequivocably a perfect corrispondence of mood, setting up and musical performance of the pieces, confirming the historical importance of this 'retrieval'.


6. Crucial proofs
At that point it was essential to get some direct proofs about the National Balkan Ensemble project, contacting single possible protagonists of that period still around - Carolyn Looker, Sweeney's wife involved to the band from the beginning, and Ben Cartland, the only musician available from the original quartet (in that period Richard Coff disappeared...).

Carolyn: "I find The National Balkan Ensemble a totally mystery. All I can think is whoever got hold of these tracks put the name to them. Before recording "Alchemy", Glen, Paul, Richard and Ben did some recordings for Ron Geesin who was going to try to sell the music for background for TV! I don't think anything came from it but maybe these are the tracks anyway, it was done in a small studio on the cheap. I vaguely remember Christopher Logue the poet being there too. Ben's leaving the band was totally his idea, he was very young - about 17! - and didn't want to commit... I think he went off with his girlfriend travelling..." (from a letter, December 2th 2005).

About Cartland, he was disappeared again (someone wrote me recently he's probably passed away...).

Then I asked Ron Geesin (on January 2th 2006) through is Web site (http://www.headscope.co.uk). His laconic answer was: "Yes, I knew the Third Ear Band because we were doing gigs on the same bill at the time, but I don't remeber ever working with them directly. That's all I can say".
In this condition of doubt, an old Nigel Cross interview with Glen Sweeney ("Unhinged" n. 6, Spring 1990) helps us to make the things clear. He said: "... we'd got this demo tape which had Ben Cartland on it - the original line-up with two violins, oboe and drums - it featured those first numbers we did at the first gigs. I can't remember what they sound like now. Geesin sold the tape to Essex Music for this library of sound effects - they must've been used on radio or TV because we got some money for them!".

So, confirming the origins of the tracks, why the Third Ear boys decided to call himself "National Balkan Ensemble"?
A convincing hypothesis is that Sweeney, usually worried about copyrights, decided to call the band so because the imminent contract signed with EMI-Harvest...

[For listening the tracks, go back at the Archive homepage and scroll on right at the free download tracks section]

no©2009 Luca Ferrari